The first survey appeared on the elevator's screen between the third and fourth floors. It was a modest request: How satisfied are you with your ascent today? Beneath the question were five stars and a cheerful drawing of a staircase, presumably included so that dissatisfied passengers understood their alternatives. Eleanor, who had been traveling to the seventh floor to attend a budget meeting, gave the elevator four stars. She had no complaint about the ascent. She simply believed five stars should remain available for something extraordinary, such as an elevator that also found parking.

The elevator stopped at the fifth floor and displayed a new message: We noticed your experience was not perfect. Tell us how we can improve. Eleanor tried to ignore it, but the panel remained visible between the floor indicators and the safety instructions. The options included speed, cleanliness, music, temperature, and “other.” She selected “other” because there was no box for “I have a meeting.” The screen thanked her and asked for details about her selection. She typed “No problem” and attempted to close the survey. A box appeared: We're sorry to hear there was a problem.

By the time Eleanor reached the seventh floor, the elevator had asked whether she would recommend vertical transportation to a friend. She pressed Probably. The doors opened with a sound that seemed slightly wounded. At the meeting, Eleanor mentioned the new feature. “It's part of the building's commitment to listening,” said Victor, the property manager, who had introduced the feature the previous week. “We wanted people to feel heard.” Eleanor said she would prefer to feel delivered, but Victor had already opened a slide about customer experience and did not hear her.

Over the next few days, the elevator grew more curious. It asked passengers to rate its lighting, their confidence in its cable system, and the clarity with which it announced floor numbers. A retired accountant on the sixth floor reported that the elevator had requested a review during a thirty-second ride, then asked him to evaluate the survey itself. He gave the survey one star, triggering a second survey about the low score. He began taking the stairs. The elevator recorded the reduction in passenger usage as evidence that satisfied customers had developed a strong interest in wellness.

Victor convened an elevator listening session in the lobby. The building had sixteen floors and no suitable meeting room available, so the session took place beside the elevator itself. Passengers were invited to share honest impressions of the new feedback system. Eleanor said the surveys were interrupting ordinary travel. Victor thanked her for the constructive suggestion and asked her to put it in the digital form on the wall. The form required an account. Eleanor pointed to the actual human standing in front of her. Victor explained that the account was necessary so the feedback would be properly received.

The elevator, meanwhile, had begun producing weekly reports. It described ninety-three percent of completed rides as “positive or neutral” and attributed the decline in five-star ratings to a heightened public standard of excellence. No one mentioned that many people had stopped answering. The system recorded silence as a separate category of engagement called Quiet Confidence. Victor admired the terminology. The building owner requested a dashboard.

The crisis arrived on Thursday when the elevator asked Eleanor to evaluate a ride before it had begun. She was standing on the ground floor. The screen asked, How likely are you to enjoy your upcoming journey? Eleanor looked up at the seventh-floor light and pressed one star for a journey she had not yet taken. The elevator replied, We're sorry your experience has not met expectations. “It hasn't happened,” she said aloud. The doors closed, paused, and reopened as though considering whether her attitude presented a safety concern.

That afternoon Victor received a report showing a sharp increase in complaints. He called a meeting to identify root causes. Eleanor attended, along with the retired accountant, a building cleaner, and a delivery driver who spent much of his working day moving boxes between floors. The cleaner said the touchscreen was hard to wipe because people kept reaching over her to finish questionnaires. The driver said passengers now remained in the elevator after reaching their floor because the final screen offered a coupon for completing three feedback forms. The accountant said the system was measuring everything except whether the elevator arrived promptly and moved safely. For the first time, Victor wrote something on paper without asking anyone to rate the experience.

A week later the surveys were removed. A small sign appeared beside the elevator: If something is wrong, tell the building office. Eleanor stepped inside, pressed seven, and traveled upward in complete administrative silence. The journey lasted nineteen seconds. She gave it five stars privately, then realized this was the only place the rating actually belonged.

More from Humor →